With every generation comes a battle of consoles – the clash between Sega and Nintendo with the Mega Drive and the SNES, later with the Sony taking the mantle as Nintendo’s N64 rival with the Playstation. Then the Playstation 2 dominated the gaming world, as Nintendo remained steady with the GameCube, and Microsoft entered the ring with the Xbox. But where are we now?
It’s a constant discussion, between friends and ‘fanboys’ – which, ultimately, is the best console? Microsoft’s Xbox 360? Sony’s Playstation 3? Or Nintendo’s Wii?
Well, today I thought I’d throw my thoughts into the ring – being a proud owner of all three consoles I’ll do my best to give a fair and justified view of the three titans of the current gaming generation.

CANDIDATE #1: THE XBOX 360
Released: December 2005
Costs: Around £200
Exclusive titles/series’: Fable, Gears of War, Halo, Lost Odyssey
The Xbox is perhaps the most popular console for serious gamers of this generation, after Microsoft crept into the game market last generation they’ve taken the world by storm – released first of the three, offering the console at an affordable price, people have really gotten to see the Xbox 360 as a fully-fledged competitor on the gaming market. With many developers moving to multi-platform sales, the Xbox 360 has access to the majority of major releases. With online play becoming standard in this generation, we now have access to online socialising, online gaming, DLC and more. There’s not much the 360 can’t do for a gamer, so it’s a good sturdy choice.
However, the Xbox has been known to have a high amount of breakages, due to a problem with the initial design – causing the dreaded RROD (Red Ring of Death). Although consoles have been improved, it’s still not unheard of – so it’s a shame Microsoft didn’t sort this out to a better standard. Still, they offered a free service for fixing this problem with a decent length of time, so they’ve tried well to make up for it.
Pros:
+ Well priced
+ Good online capabilities
+ Large choice of titles
+ Selective backward compatibility with Xbox titles
Cons:
- Prone to breakages (although improving)
- Online gaming costs money (around £40 a year)
- Loud console due to fans
- Some Xbox games not backward compatible
- Must buy an adaptor for wireless internet connectivity
Next we have…

CANDIDATE #2: THE PLAYSTATION 3
Released: March 2007
Costs: Around £250 for a Slim, or £300 for the original
Exclusive titles/series’: Final Fantasy Versus XIII (upcoming), God of War III (Upcoming), LittleBigPlanet, Metal Gear Solid 4, Ninja Gaiden Sigma, Uncharted
The Playstation 2 was an excellent console, winning the console battle by a mile last generation (in my eyes). So, naturally, I looked forward to the PS3. However, a lot went wrong concerning it’s release. Firstly, it got delayed quite badly – already due for release after the Xbox 360, it was put back even further until it was eventually released in March 2007 – over a year after Microsoft’s release. Not only that, though – the console was priced at over a whopping £400. The pricing was largely due to the consoles Blu-Ray capability and expensive hardware. This meant that the PS3 was highly slated, and many gamers opted for the more affordable Xbox 360.
However, I did get hold of one eventually, due to my love of God of War and Final Fantasy, both of which have exclusive titles lined up in the future. A couple of years later on from it’s initial release, I could finally appreciate the console for what it was. Sharing many of the titles with the Xbox 360 in the multi platform market, and with a host of exclusive titles of it’s own, the PS3 is a mighty piece of hardware. Along with titles such as LittleBigPlanet and Uncharted, and it’s exciting line up of future titles, the PS3 also offered Blu-Ray capability, a powerful engine, and free online play. However, Sony removed PS2 backward compatibility to the newer consoles to make it cheaper – sadly meaning it’s unable to play the large library the PS2 has to offer. It’s rumored that this will be fixed in a future update, but I’m not too sure.
The PS3 has a lot of pros and cons, but this year has seen the release of the more affordable PS3 Slim, which may just tip the scales for the PS3’s future.
Pros:
+ Totally free online functionality
+ Large choice of titles
+ Backward compatible with PS1, allowing game saving to HDD
+ Large hard disk comes as standard
+ Less prone to breakages than the Xbox
+ Quiet console
+ Doubles as Blu-Ray player
+ Built in Wi-fi
Cons:
- The most expensive console of the three (although the Slim is cheaper)
- Online socialising not as user friendly as the Xbox
- Currently no PS2 backward compatibility (apart from select early models)
- More people often have Xbox 360’s than PS3’s for online play
- Games often have initial installation requirements that are simple, yet may cause a wait when booting a new game for the first time
Lastly we have:

CANDIDATE #3: THE NINTENDO WII
Released: December 8th 2006
Costs: Around £180
Exclusive titles/series’: Fire Emblem, Metroid, Red Steel, Super Mario, Super Smash Bros, Zelda. Also specific ‘Wii’ titles such as Wii Fit and Wii Sports
Nintendo made an unusual move in their latest console, moving away from traditional gaming by inventing a motion controller for use with a new style of game. The console is a much more family oriented design, created in a way to mimic real movements with on-screen cursors and images. Nintendo have also taken their biggest franchises to the Wii with some fantastic additions to the Mario, Zelda, Metroid and Smash Bros series’, among others, implementing the motion controls in well alongside the regular gameplay – enhancing them with fun, precise controls.
However, the move to motion controls has introduced a line-up of badly ported games with motion controls ‘tacked on’ to the games’ button based engines, and far too many party games, many of which are of low quality – selling on the ‘innovation’ factor of the motion controls, and the easy target market of parents and the entire age spectrum – which is a shame, since Nintendo have proved that the console can work wonderfully if used well.
Pros:
+ Cheapest of the consoles, costing less than £200
+ Nintendo’s main titles are fantastically well designed
+ Controls can be fun for many people
+ Completely backward compatible with GameCube titles and controllers
+ Completely free online play, although not many games support it
+ Quiet console
+ In built wireless
Cons:
- Buying all of the controllers and accessories (Nunchuks, Wii MotionPlus) is expensive, raising the total cost to as much as the PS3 if you buy enough for 4 players, and are mandatory for many titles
- The weakest hardware of the three consoles, with graphics similar to the GameCube
- Overly child-protective online making communication and online play difficult
- Controllers require batteries, with no wired alternative
- Good games are rare, low quality games are plenty
- Some games require wide movement space, so aren’t very good unless in a living room or equally open area.
- No ethernet port for wired internet
- Small hard disk (although expandable via SD card)
- No DVD or CD play capability like the other consoles
RESULT
As I said initially, there’s not really a clear winner, its very much up to the individual. But here’s my view – if you want a solid console at a good price, go with the PS3 Slim. A little while ago, I would say the Xbox 360, since the price difference was rather large. However, with the Slim being more affordable, the little extra cost goes a long way – giving you a quieter console, with free online play and lots of extras. However, the Xbox 360 is still very much the popular choice, meaning its often more likely to know other people to game with – but be warned, the constant cost of Xbox Live builds up more than you may realise – making it actually more expensive than the PS3 in the long run. If you’re not bothered about online play, its really up to you if you want to save the cash by going with the 360.
However, if you’re looking for something more casual, the Wii may be the way to go. It’s got some fun family games, but beware that they are often short-lived, and the costs of the accessories raise the console’s overall price. However, there are some real gems amidst the legions of casual games, making the Wii worthwhile; Nintendo always put the hard work in with their main titles.
All in all, I believe the PS3 is the dark (albeit late) horse this generation, but only time will tell. It really could go any way.
-Leon
